sam_and_liv wrote:The problem with scotch essences is that none of them taste remotely like scotch :handgestures-thumbdown: Most of them are really sweet. The best by far is using the whisky profile kit but at the end of the day it is still an essence and you can taste that it is.
Better off soaking on chips/staves/dominoes then adding some peat essence or peat treek.
Or go for a Mac whisky or some variant and add some peat to it :handgestures-thumbupleft:
As for making Johnny Walker if you like it then try to replicate it but you can make something a whole lot better ;-)
SnL is quite right here, it'll never BE what the world calls whisky. However, I've had SOME success with SS Top Shelf essences and oaking the mixture.
In particular the Irish Whiskey, but I like a bit of the sweetness in it.
At the end of the day you'll need to experiment and just make something you like. The taste of whiskey is like the taste of wine...people can rattle on about the complexities and differences of the good stuff till the cows come home, but the bad stuff, everyone can agree on.
Just make some good stuff.