Nakiman wrote:I am now to distilling and want to make my own scotch style malt whisky.
Welcome Down The Rabbit Hole! :greetings-waveyellow:
I realize this is more than a little late, I just saw this.
First thing - FULL Disclosure - I have NEVER attempted a "scotch style malt whiskey".
It's even been a while since I've done an All Grain.
And I apologize - I'm a little confused about the Batch 1 and 2 and if you've done the stripping run on which batch?
That said, the ingredients you described are let's say
NOT GOOD for what you are looking for.
You had more sugar than grain so the alcohol from the sugar should bury the grain taste you are looking for.
And the EC-1118 - my go-to - is NOT the yeast for a malt. I'm using it for a HIGH ABV NEUTRAL Sugar Wash.
You want taste, I want none.
You've gotten a good introduction to the craft,
let me suggest you read through Tried & True Recipes until you find one that makes you go AHA :happy-partydance:
The great thing about T&T is that it's not just a recipe it's a roadmap to get to your destination, including where the potholes are
so hopefully you don't hit them.
I was carefully monitoring the temperature at 4 points
I'm not familiar with your still at all. I started with a copper pot with thumper and worm. I simplified to a Vevor Water Distiller Air Still with a power controller.
Even with the copper pot, the ONLY time to EVER worry about temperature is when you are mashing in and fermenting.
That's it.
My copper pot had a thermometer, completely irrelevant. Adjust the gas to control the flow.
With the VW, I set temp to MAX - 108c and turn the power control down to around 70%, even on stripping runs. I do Low & Slow.
Watching the liquor NOT the thermometer.
By the way, did you do a Sacrificial Run with the still before either of the runs? If you didn't, now you did.
Conventional Wisdom & Safety Protocols :law-policered: say don't even TASTE a Sac Run. Toss that Shit.